Birth and Death, Growth and Decay, Joy and Suffering are all part of natural cycle of Life. Likewise Bubble and Burst are part of any market cycle- be it Stock Market, Derivatives Market, Commodities Market, Forex Market, Real Estate Market…… you name anything, they go through these cycles.
As there is no way we can escape the natural cycle of life, we cannot also escape the market cycles, however clever and astute we are. Those of you who have attended my market presentations know how non-investing is also risky. This is similar to the scenario that by simply sitting in home and not doing anything also, you cannot escape from the problems of life. Then problems come home searching for you!
So how to face these bubbles and bursts of market cycles? As I always highlight, having a right asset allocation (which is unique for each individual) and not being driven by greed or fear help you to minimise the damages and optimise the returns. But the fact is that you cannot avoid losses totally, however minimal it is, even if you diligently follow the above.
In this article I’m going to write about a bubble which happened three centuries ago in stock market, in which even the greatest genius Sir Isaac Newton lost most part of his wealth. This had such an emotional impact on him, he lamented and made a statement “I can calculate the movement of the stars, but not the madness of men”.
Warren Buffett was not born then and Newton never had the opportunity of hearing him saying “A pin lies in wait for every bubble and when the two eventually meet, a new wave of investors learns some very old lessons“.
I’m also glad to note here that based on the letter written by Buffett recently to his stake holders it looks like an Indian, Ajit Jain may succeed him. This would be another feather in India’s / Indians’ achievements.
Now let’s get into the South Sea Bubble!
In the year 1720, the whole of England got involved in a bubble known as the ‘South Sea Bubble’. Many investors, including Sir Isaac Newton and Jonathan Swift lost substantial amounts in this bubble.
The South Sea Company was founded in 1711. In 1720, the company was granted the monopoly of trade with Spain’s South American by the British government in return for a loan of £ 7 m to wage a war against France. The monopoly of trade and the company’s relationship with the government helped the South Sea company in attracting large numbers of investors.
Shares immediately rose by 10 times, further attracting more investors towards the stock. To satiate the investors’ appetite, the company issued fresh equity in four subscriptions, at higher and higher prices. It also lent generously against its own shares, thereby increasing demand for them.
The success of South Sea stirred the British market and investors started believing that British companies are the best. Taking cue from the South Sea Company, several other companies launched their IPOs and they all sold like hot cakes.
Nobody questioned the repeated re-issue of stocks nor did anybody check the quality of the company’s management. Investors kept on buying expensive stocks as fast as they were offered. Interestingly, the company’s directors set up opulently furnished offices in the most extravagant localities to attract further investments.
Very soon, the massive trading started putting pressure on the settlement process. The South Sea Company closed its books in order to catch up with the backlog and to prepare for the future subscriptions. Meanwhile, rumours about the company’s bad financial state started circulating in the market. As a result, a large number of investors started selling when the books were reopened. The company was found short of cash to pay the debt holders. The stock price declined.
The directors promised dividends of 50% of the stock’s face value in a desperate bid to push up the sinking stock price. For this, the company used its financial arm “The Sword Blade Company”. But very soon, in September 1720, Sword Blade became insolvent. Following this event, the price of South Sea stock plummeted. This sent shock waves in the market and stock prices started declining across the board creating a terrible financial mess.
Speculation can inflate stock prices to unbelievable levels. Investors find these escalating prices very enticing. As an investor, one’s focus must be on the intrinsic value of a company and not its fluctuating market prices. Those who pay attention to intrinsic values might underperform during bubbles, but they often have the last laugh. As Benjamin Graham says “The individual investor should act consistently as an investor and not as a speculator. This means… that he should be able to justify every purchase he makes and each price he pays by impersonal, objective reasoning that satisfies him that he is getting more than his money’s worth for his purchase.”
(with inputs from Equitymaster)